Selecting the Perfect Chew Toy for Your Dog: The Ultimate Guide

Selecting the Perfect Chew Toy for Your Dog: The Ultimate Guide

Choosing the right chew toy for your dog is an important decision that can make or break the relationship between you and your pet. Not only do chew toys help to keep your dog entertained, but they also provide important dental care benefits.

When selecting a chew toy for your dog, it’s important to consider their size, energy level, and chewing needs. For smaller dogs, softer toys are generally best as they won’t hurt their gums while they teethe. For larger dogs, harder toys may be more suitable as they will last longer and can handle more intense playtime activities.

In this guide, we’ll cover the different types of chew toys available on the market and provide some tips for selecting the perfect chew toy for your pup. We’ll also discuss how to ensure that your pet is using their new chew toy safely and happily!

Determine Your Dog's Chewing Style: Gentle or Aggressive

When selecting the perfect chew toy for your dog, the first step is to determine your pup's chewing style. Your pup may be a gentle chewer or an aggressive chewer, based on their temperament and distinct personality.

Gentle chewers often prefer softer materials like plush toys and rubber toys. Plush toys provide entertainment, give them something to snuggle up with, and can be great stress relievers. Rubber chew toys are often durable and provide a great way for them to groom their chompers while playing with it.

Aggressive chewers require strong and durable materials such as nylon or natural rubber that can endure vigorous chew sessions. Nylon toys come in various shapes, sizes, colors and textures that help alleviate boredom during those long days when you're away at work. Natural rubber toys are perfect for teething puppies who are transitioning into adult teeth; they provide relief by massaging the gums and entertain your pup with erratic bounce upon every toss.

No matter what type of chewer your pup is, finding the right kind of toy ensures it'll last longer—and won't add to your expense of replacing a toy every few weeks!

Choose Durable Materials Based on Your Dog's Chewing Habits

When selecting a chew toy for your dog, it’s important to choose one that is made of strong and durable materials. After all, when your pup starts to bite and gnaw on their toy, you’ll want to make sure it can withstand the pressure.

To ensure you select the best material for your canine companion’s chewing habits, consider the following:

  • For heavy chewers who prefer soft toys: If your pup likes to chew fabrics but also tears them apart easily, opt for soft yet durable toys such as fabric stuffed animals or braided ropes.

  • For medium chewers: If your pup likes a harder surface but doesn’t chew too aggressively, rubber toys are a great option. Be sure to look for one with a thick wall that can handle lots of biting and gnawing.

  • For light chewers: If your pup isn't an aggressive chewer, look for lightweight plastic toys that will stand up against occasional chomping without disintegrating.

No matter which material you select, make sure it's safe and non-toxic—especially if filling the toy with treats or snacks. Quality materials such as natural rubber, nylon and canvas will keep your pup barking happily while they play with their new toy!

Pick Appropriate Shapes and Textures for Your Dog's Needs

Choosing an appropriate chew toy for your pup isn't just about finding something they will enjoy - it's also about providing them with something that will meet their specific needs.


There are a variety of shapes to choose from, but not all are the best for your pet. For instance, soft toys are great for cuddling, but they don't offer much in terms of dental hygiene. On the other hand, hard-shaped toys (such as rubber disks and balls) can help clean teeth and massage gums - just make sure that whatever shape you choose is large enough that it won't be able to fit completely in their mouth so there's no risk of choking or swallowing.


The texture of a chew toy can also make a difference in how much your pup enjoys playing with it. For instance, rope toys provide an interesting tactile experience and help relieve teething pain - just ensure that the material isn't too rough so as to avoid damaging your pet's gums or teeth.

Soft plush toys may not have the same kind of dental benefits as rope toys, but they can still be enjoyable options for cuddling and snuggling up with when it's time to relax. Look for fabrics with interesting textures such as corduroy and fleece for added comfort and amusement!

Consider Interactive Toys to Keep Your Dog Engaged

One of the best ways to keep your pup entertained and engaged is by providing them with interactive toys. These can come in the form of puzzles, treat balls, Kongs and more. Not only do these help entice your pup to use their problem solving skills and keep their mind sharp, they also provide a fun way to release pent up energy and boredom.

Interactive toys offer several advantages over traditional chew toys:

  • They encourage problem solving skills and help to improve cognitive development

  • They give dogs something new to explore and experiment with

  • The challenge helps keep their minds active, reducing the chances of boredom or destructive behavior

  • They are often refillable with treats or kibble, adding an extra level of excitement as they try to solve the puzzle

Factor in Your Dog's Size When Selecting Chew Toys

The size of your pup should always be taken into consideration when selecting a chew toy. If a toy is too small, it can become an accidental choking hazard. On the other hand, if it's too big, your pup may not be able to comfortably grip it in their mouths.

When in doubt, select a product that is slightly larger than the size of your dog's mouth. Here are some guidelines for finding the right size for your pup:

  • For dogs under 15 pounds: look for toys less than 3 inches wide and 5 inches long

  • For dogs between 15 and 35 pounds: look for toys between 3 and 4 inches wide and 5 to 7 inches long

  • For dogs over 35 pounds: look for toys larger than 4 inches wide and 7 inches long

Remember, these sizes are just general recommendations - every dog is different so you'll want to make sure you select a chew toy that's right for YOUR pup!

Avoid Toys With Small Parts to Prevent Choking Hazards

Chew toys are meant to provide a safe and fun way for your pup to satisfy their natural urge to chew - but not all chew toys are created equal! To ensure that your pup stays safe and healthy, it's important to select chew toys that are both durable and appropriate for their individual needs - as well as avoiding any dangerous choking hazards.

Small parts from broken or chewed-up toys can be a hazard if ingested. Many popular toy materials, such as rubber, vinyl, natural fibers, and rope can be easily broken down into tiny pieces. To avoid this issue, it's important to select toys made of durable materials such as nylon or other comparable plastics. Some manufacturers may also add extra reinforcement to the edges or handle of their chew toys to make them extra-resistant to wear and tear. When in doubt, inspect the toy before you buy it and test its strength with a brief squeeze or tug.


In conclusion, selecting the perfect chew toy for your dog is not as daunting as it may seem. Choosing a toy based on the size, preferences, and chewing habits of your dog is paramount to ensure the safety and enjoyment of your pet.

When selecting the perfect chew toy for your dog, consider the type of chew toy your dog will like best and make sure that the toy is durable and safe. Additionally, make sure to supervise your dog whenever they are playing with the chew toy for your own peace of mind. With proper selection and usage, your dog will enjoy playing with their chew toy for years to come.

Tags: Dog Toys, Tip & Tricks